THE PRESENCE LETTER

Issue 05 • November 2026

The Stories We Carry About Each Other

Long friendships accumulate history almost without our noticing. We share milestones, hear stories more than once, and watch parts of one another's lives unfold over the years. There's a certain comfort in that familiarity. We develop a sense of each other's personalities, beliefs, and expectations. We recognize patterns and come to expect certain things of one another.

But what we expect from someone and what they actually think or feel aren't always the same. We may know their professional history, the decisions they've made, and how they've responded to difficult circumstances. Much of that information tells us what they've done or how they've behaved. It doesn't necessarily tell us why. And even when we once understood their reasons, those reasons can change.

Sometimes that realization comes through an ordinary conversation. You're catching up with a longtime friend when a familiar subject comes up. You remember how strongly they once felt about it, and you expect to hear an opinion you've heard before. Instead, they pause. They explain that they see things differently now. Perhaps watching their children navigate adulthood has changed how they think about offering advice. Or perhaps an experience you knew little about has caused them to reconsider something they once believed firmly.

There's no dramatic revelation. Just a different perspective from someone whose views you thought you understood. And you realize that while you've continued thinking of your friend in familiar ways, their experiences have been quietly reshaping how they see the world.

We don't simply observe people. We interpret them. And over time, those interpretations become the stories we believe about who they are.

Those stories aren't necessarily wrong. They may reflect someone we genuinely knew, shaped by circumstances we experienced together. But the impressions we carry don't always evolve alongside the people who formed them. What's interesting is that we experience this from the other side, too.

We know how much our own perspectives have changed over the years. The things we once considered important, the beliefs we've reconsidered, the ambitions that have taken different forms. Some changes were intentional. Others emerged gradually through experiences we never anticipated. Yet people who've known us for decades may still remember the opinions we once defended or the priorities that once defined us. Sometimes we recognize ourselves in those memories. Other times, we recognize someone we used to be.

There's something reassuring about being remembered by people who've shared our history. But there's also something quietly unsettling about realizing that their understanding of us may belong to an earlier chapter of our lives. Perhaps that's part of what makes understanding another person so difficult.

We can remember someone exactly as they were and still miss who they're becoming.

David McNaney

Editor, The Presence Letter
Founder, Chicago High-End Headshots

Explore The Presence Letter
View All Issues →